why amazing spider man 2 failed

People were not conscious about the spider verse, back when TASM was released. This is the gear shiftThe Amazing Spider-Man needed in order to differentiate itself - not just reinstate the mechanical web shooters and shave a few years off Aunt May. How to catch up on the Spider-Man movies without watching them. No, Peter Parker just loves science so dearly (and is so thoroughly rejected by the popular kids) that he likes to spend his time discussing the finer points of atomic energy. So we get a sequel to the incredibly overrated "The Amazing Spider-Man" film and it turns out to be s**t? Seeing the potential profitability in this method of movie making, other studios started to take note, including Sony Pictures. Of course when Andrew took the role of Spider-Man people took it too serious. The first arrived in 2004 and the second hit cinema screens in 2007. The Goblin was introduced late The big storytelling innovation the mystery of Peter Parker's parents was a non-starter, anchoring the entire series with a question that no one cared enough to see answered. Now all of that out of the way I'm gonna explain what I didn't like. The Amazing Spider-Man 2 was the definition of lackluster. Of course, with Sony holding the movie rights to the character, he remained trapped in his own cinematic universe. Story is mess. Please reference Error Code 2121 when contacting customer service. All images on this blog are the right of their respective owners unless otherwise stated. Why space experts want to establish a lunar time zone, Jupiter and Venus to 'kiss' in the night sky Wednesday evening, Hyundai recalls 65,000 cars over possible exploding seatbelts. In defense of Webb, it's very clear that Sony sought to use asThe Amazing Spider-Man 2 as a launch pad toother things. I really liked The Amazing Spider-man (my favourite), but this movie didn't work for me. When The Amazing The story is pretty convoluted and all over the place. Dane DeHaan does what he can with the character, but hes let down by the script. Anyone who gets to playSpider-Man is living a dream come true. With a stellar cast starring Tobey Maguire, Kirsten Dunst, Willem Dafoe and James Franco, web-mania was in full effect, and a 2004 sequel that pitted Spidey against Alfred Molina's Doctor Octopus is widely considered even greater than the original. Dont get me wrong, Andrew Garfield was a fantastic choice as the new Peter Parker, but theres only so much the actor can do with such average material. Today I talk about "The Amazing Spider-Man #2", which is where the Vulture first showed up. really went away. Most recently, he starred in Under the Silver Lake, a neo-noir that takes his character across Los Angeles in pursuit of conspiracy. The movie burned time on a watered-down version of the origin story everybody already knew anyway. Whatever the cynical motives behind the near-instant reboot, nearly everyone agrees that The Amazing Spider-Man got two thingsright: Andrew Garfield and Emma Stone. It drags on for nearly two and a half hours, and culminates with a version of a legendary comic-book moment that comes with the unfortunate side effect of killing off the movie's most interesting character. It was reported that Sony had plans to expand the Spiderman universe; however, due to the sequel drawing its lowest financial number yet, the studio canceled any further plans for The Amazing Spiderman. Two years later, The Amazing Spiderman 2 came out, with Dan DeHaan as the new Green Goblin, Jamie Foxx as Electro, and Paul Giamatti as Rhino. Firstly, it would have to be that the film was a lazy Spider-Man 3 copy and paste (in terms of Harry Osborn at the end). Just confirm how you got your ticket. Well, definitely not Marc Webb, because he manages the movie with all the same mistakes he made in the first movie, and even more. the Terms and Policies, and to receive email from Rotten Tomatoes. It was not, as the title practically begged critics to pun, "amazing.". Paul Giamatti is way too over the top as Rhino and he is humiliated in the beginning and he only comes back for the end of the movie, the trailers pretty much lied to you and it was really disappointing. The Amazing Spider-Man 2 doubles down on all the misstepsof the original while adding a few of its own. And when his old friend Harry Osborn (Dane DeHaan) returns, Peter comes to realize that all his enemies have one thing in common: Oscorp. Answer (1 of 4): To be perfectly blunt, they didn't know what the hell they were doing. It's interesting to do a postmortem," Emma Stone's co-star and boyfriend said. Remember the upside-down kiss, and perhapsabove all, remember that iconic train rescue. But before we put The Amazing Spider-Man into the ground, it at least deserves anautopsy. More: All The Times Spider-Man ALMOST Joined The MCU Before Civil War. Illustrated | Sony Pictures, Wikimedia Commons, krishh/iStock. It is debatable as to whether it was a good thing or a bad thing to remove these plot lines, but they demonstrate quite clearly that this Spidey picture had a bit too much going on. Hollywood is a machine of dreams, fed by the grist of hardship. Confident in his powers as Spider-Man, Peter Parker (Andrew Garfield) embraces his new role as a hero and spends time with Gwen Stacy (Emma Stone) in between protecting New York from criminals. It clearly didnt learn the lesson that made Spiderman 3 a hated film. On the bright side, Peter Parker isnt dancing like a dork. The CGI is goofier and . '", Unfortunately, the studio didn't agree. If that doesn't impress you, recall that this means it did better than two Disney juggernauts (Brave and Wreck-It Ralph), The Hunger Games, and Les Miserables. Second thing : its shoulder be more villians because this is the the adventure Cookies help us deliver our Services. Directed by Marc Webb, the Spidey movie reboot took Peter Parker's story right back to the beginning, with a younger version of the superhero and a more stylized visual approach. What happened? Disney doesn't really have much to do with it. Through no fault of the actors, Garfield's Peter is prone to being unlikable and their constant troubles dampen Gwen's eventual death. When tasked with reviving the failingBatman movie franchise, for example, Christopher Nolan opted to takeBatman Begins into previously unexplored territory, adopting an urban realism that was a world away from Tim Burton and Joel Schumacher. primary focus for the majority of the story, but he wasnt alone. Unfortunately, the sequel received the first rotten tomatoes of the Spiderman films and made only $709 million worldwide. Other gripes I had was the choice of songs in scenes, character logic and villain motivation, and the fact that it was painfully obvious that they were trying to set up a Sinister Six movie and universe. Marvel Movies Ranked Worst to Best by Tomatometer, Jurassic Park Movies Ranked By Tomatometer, The Mandalorian Season 3 First Reviews: Still the Best Star Wars TV Show, Critics Say. Website: debatingmarvelpodcast.weebly.com Feedback: anchor.fm/debating-marvel Find us on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, OverCast, Audible, or Amazon Music! It also became one of the lowest-rated superhero shows on television at the time, since it had to contend with more successful programs like The Incredible Hulk and Wonder Woman.. The Amazing Spider-Man 2 is an inauspicious fail for Beenox, the Quebec City-based developer responsible for the previous trio of console games starring everyone's favourite wall-crawler. But why? Now, a worldwide gross of $709 million isn't anything to sneeze at, but when you compare how it fared against other 2014 releases, the slippage is obvious. Coming Soon, Regal Garfield's Spider-Man was on a downward trend, and against superhero films on the rise, even a tumble just a couple of spots down the charts was unforgivable. Verified reviews are considered more trustworthy by fellow moviegoers. Xenoblade Chronicles for the Wii is still $50 lol. Raimi's Spiderman 1 and 2 were damned good and helped to kick off the comic movie craze, It was way too soon for a re . Your AMC Ticket Confirmation# can be found in your order confirmation email. Regards, By creating an account, you agree to the Someone please help. And while that's a wonderful part of the story, it's only one piece in the complex puzzle that makes up a successful spin on Spider-Man. For all the technical and story analysis, perhaps the overriding reasonThe Amazing Spider-Man failed to make the same impact as Sam Raimi's trilogy or Tom Holland's MCU iteration is that fans simply aren't inclined to care about the characters. Subsequently, it's no surprise that a sizable chunk ofThe Amazing Spider-Man's woes can be attributed to lackluster villains. The former Page 3 model, who shot to fame after being spotted on a billboard for a windows firm in Swindon in 1997, celebrated her 52nd birthday last week. In this post, I will answer this question by taking a look at all of the elements of the film which are often seen to be problematic. The image is an example of a ticket confirmation email that AMC sent you when you purchased your ticket. Related: How Sony Ruined (And Then Saved) Spider-Man. The film also didnt perform as well as its predecessors, which only added to the negative stories surrounding the movie. Sony's Amazing Spider-Man movies starring Andrew Garfield had plenty going for them, but ended abruptly. turned supervillain. The Amazing Spider-Man 2 teased a slew of popular villainsthat were supposed toappear in future installments, including Doctor Octopus, Vulture, and Kraven the Hunter. Get the freshest reviews, news, and more delivered right to your inbox! Actress Shailene Woodley filmed scenes for the movie, but the footage was never used in the final edit. Overall The Amazing Spider-Man 2 is mediocre at best. You're almost there! OK, so first up it is important to put this film (and its predecessor) In fairness,The Amazing Spider-Man does make one significant shake-up to the familiar formula but it's not one that lands as intended. Ock had nor was their fun and wild energy coming from him like Green Goblin. The order of the Marvel Hachette The Ultimate Graphic Novels Collection. Andrew Garfield did an amazing job at playing Spider-Man back then. And it's hard to drum up much affection or sympathy for the Amazing Spider-Man franchise, which came much too soon afterRaimi's Spider-Man trilogy, and lacked the courage to do anything truly interesting with the character. What Spider-Man movie should I watch next. received by audiences and made a lot of money at the box office. Fewer still stay there for long. This was a decision which didnt sit well with fans of the previous movies. The Amazing Spider-Man lacks anything that comes close to bottling that same magic, and it's a curious phenomenon. And taking to Instagram on Monday . So, what happened? 2023 E! Heres the thing, I dont know the whole behind-the-scenes reason that Sony couldnt have just kept Tobey McGuire and hire a new director instead. Amazing 2 was the ninth most profitable film of 2014, and far less critically successful than its predecessor. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Dont Tell Harry is a fan blog. Garfields run as Spider-Man ended with the second film, with Sony choosing to arrive at an arrangement with Marvel Studios to allow the character to appear in the MCU films. Since joining the Screen Rant fold, Craig has been involved in breaking news stories and mildly controversial ranking lists, but now works predominantly as a features writer. Ock had nor was their fun and wild energy coming from him like Green Goblin. introducing characters (Felicia Hardy, Alistair Smythe etc) and situations (Osborns Once you start removing things and saying, 'No, that doesn't work,' then the thread is broken, and it's hard to go with the flow of the story. I love movies and television. He's just too cool, and when it comes to Spider-Man, that's a fatal flaw. That is a gift for me and a big burden to carry. But it's not long enough for a generation to turn over. Electro is the one who gets the most character development, but theres nothing particularly memorable about him. They won't be able to see your review if you only submit your rating. a live-action Spidey movie from director Sam Raimi. As star of The Amazing Spider-Man and The Amazing Spider-Man 2, he brought Peter Parker to moody, wall-crawling life, battling classic villains like the Lizard and Electro as he romanced Gwen Stacy. Heres the thing, I dont know the whole behind-the-scenes reason that Sony couldnt have just kept Tobey McGuire and hire a new director instead. How many children don the iconic mask and pretend to spray web-shooters at pets, claiming they're on their way to rescue their beloved Mary Jane? Ever since Tom Holland took up the webbed suit to flip and quip his way through the MCU's sprawling saga, Garfield has devoted himself almost entirely to cerebral and even arthouse cinema. Sony was wise for skipping an origin story for Tom Hollands version of Spiderman. Coming Soon. If there's one indisputable high point of the Amazing Spider-Man movies, it's the romance between Peter Parker and Gwen Stacy. Worse still, the answers come via an extremely convenient video message that Peter really should've found an entire film ago. Yet as it marches toward a plausible $700m+ global total, the box office performance of The Amazing Spider-Man 2 feels incredibly disappointing. Using this idea of world building, Sony began to include a Alas, the dream was brief. As a general rule of thumb, the Spider-Man movies are well received by audiences. The bad news? The Amazing Spider-Man 2 premiered several years later, and this would prove to be the final chapter in Webb's aborted version of the web-slinger. There was too much going on. In every single aspect. Nevertheless,the fact that the famous red and blue suit is currently occupied by Tom HollandprovesThe Amazing Spider-Man series clearly didn't go to plan, and here's why: Superhero movies so often boil down to the strength of their villains; it's no coincidence that the reveredThe Dark Knight starred Heath Ledger's Joker, while the MCU's black sheep,Thor: The Dark World, also had the franchise's most forgettable villain in Malekith. To succeed as an actor, you need both thick skin and flexibility. In 2017, he played a Polio survivor in the biopic Breathe. GAME WONT START. The good news is that the sequel deviates from any of Raimis sequels. The reboot made a solid return of $757.9 million, though the reviews of the popular web-slinger were a far cry from the high praise that both Spiderman and Spiderman 2 received. Copyright Fandango. into context when discussing the Spider-Man movie series. Instead, Sony opted to start from scratch and five years later, The Amazing Spiderman was born. How could we improve it? Based on various reports and Sam Raimi himself, the split between the director and Sony was amicable; however, the studio was clearly planning for a reboot even before Spiderman 4 was announced (and then canceled). Instead, Sony opted to start from scratch and five years later, The Amazing Spiderman was born. Publication history. Its the fact that the writers failed to separate The Amazing Spiderman from the Sam Raimi series. Not so amazing, at all. Instead, The Amazing Spiderman felt like an unnecessary cash cow because the Peter Parker name is familiar to mainstream audiences. This film was terrible for many reasons. Compare this tothe MCU's Vulture and Mysterio. With origins and reintroductions out of the way, there was no reason The Amazing Spider-Man 2 couldn't shakeoff the pop-cultural hangover from Raimi'smovies and forge its own trail. The supporting case was bland, the villain was forgettable, and the movie ends with Spider-Man smirkingly breaking a promise to his girlfriend's dying dad. Since The Amazing Spider-Man's cancelation, its Japanese counterpart Spider-Man largely overshadowed the former's place in . Also, a better name for this movie should have been "Sinister Six's Crappy Prequel!". The Amazing Spiderman isnt a bad movie. The Amazing Spider-Man also made adjustments to Spider-Man's (very) familiar origin story but,once again, the changes fall flat. Today, most critics and Spider-fans aren't even bothering to wave goodbye to the Amazing Spider-Man as they look to a (presumably) brighter future. Lets dive into several theories on why The Amazing Spiderman movies failed to truly connect with most audiences. IfThe Amazing Spider-Man was underwhelming, the sequel was overstuffed. Check. here and there, The Amazing Spider-Man 2 pressed firmly on world building, And that might have been difficult for some people., Garfield had always been candid about his second Spider-Man films poor reception, and not shy about assigning blame. The CGI is goofier and the direction is more frenetic. If the end of Spider-Man pushed Garfield into this kind of work, its as much a blessing as it is a curse and perhaps Garfield himself feels the same way. There's a bigger lesson here: Whatever this new Spider-Man turns out to be, he can't look anything like the Spider-Mans we've seen before. Ben Kingsley and John Malkovich, among others, were rumored to have been slated for the role, but the plan was shut down when Venom was added to Spider-Man 3 's roster. However, a third installment of the franchise was cancelled after it failed to connect with the audience. "Hopefully, we can get underneath what the criticism was about, and if we missed anything.". Peter Parker struggles to balance his superhero antics with his love life, while a scientific mentor begins a slow descent into madness and villainy in pursuit of progress at any cost, forcing Spider-Man to fight a man he once held in high esteem. As cheesy as it might've been, the duo's upside-down kiss is an iconic cinematic moment. Maguire remained an A-list star, rather than an elder statesman passing down a beloved role. Your expectations must be kept, somehow, simultaneously high and low, with a positively Herculean degree of persistence. But a thoughtful, original story those are always in demand. Craig first began contributing to Screen Rant in 2016, several years after graduating college, and has been ranting ever since, mostly to himself in a darkened room. Cinemark Though he's in his early 30s, Garfield possesses the look, the style, and the boyishness that a young Peter Parker requires. There's no one right answer, formula, or concept like any genre, it's a balancing act each team must figure out for themselves. In the bid to reboot and then in the bid to. None had kids of their own. Spider-Man story and not everyone was a fan of this. But beyond causing clashes between creative aims and budgetary concerns, it also likely played a role in pushing Garfield toward other directors. The romance while at times good, the dialogue needed some work. With the emergence of Electro (Jamie Foxx), Peter must confront an enemy far more powerful than he is. The Amazing Spider-Man 2 is an open world action-adventure video game based on the Marvel Comics character Spider-Man and the 2014 film of the same name.Developed by Beenox, it is the sequel to 2012's The Amazing Spider-Man, and takes place within the same continuity, different from that of the films.The game's plot expands upon that of the film by including additional characters and elements . Once you start removing things and saying, No, that doesnt work, then the thread is broken, and its hard to go with the flow of the story., Also read: The real reason Marvel fired Edward Norton from Avengers, replaced him with Mark Ruffalo as Hulk, More recently, in one of Varietys Actors on Actors sessions, he told Amy Adams, I signed up to serve the story and serve this incredible character that Ive been dressing as since I was three, and then it gets compromised and it breaks your heart. Despite all of this, Stone and Garfield had a chemistry no fan or critic could deny. The Amazing Spider-Man 2 just might be setting itself up for a similar fate, given that we already know that Paul Giamatti is playing Rhino and Jamie Foxx is portraying Electro, while Dane. Instead, Sony opted to start from scratch and five years later, The Amazing Spiderman was born. Spider-Man 2 was so tightly packed that the film ultimately had to drop a Stay up-to-date on all the latest Rotten Tomatoes news! Adventure, the best spiderman feature. Just below that it reads "Ticket Confirmation#:" followed by a 10-digit number. (If only that radioactive spider had bitten her instead.) Electro's introduction, the emergence of Green Goblin, Peter and Gwen's relationship woes, the Parker family's secrets, the true intentions of Oscorp, Gwen's death and various smaller side stories are all left battling for screen time. Didn't everyone agree that he and Stone positively crackled on screen? the films followed the traditional pattern of movie making i.e. I love movies and television. The sequel failed to match the hype or success of its predecessor from 2011, debuting in May 2014 to lackluster reviews and disappointing. Not for extra credit, and not because he works there. "For me, I read the script that [Alex Kurtzman] and [Bob Orci] wrote, and I genuinely loved it. Gwens death was inevitable she was killed in the comics during the 1970s but it still came as a shock to those unfamiliar with her comic book history. Unfortunately, the sequel received the first rotten tomatoes of the Spiderman films and made only $709 million worldwide. How Many Phases Will the MCU Actually Have? The 2012 reboot was essentially a carbon copy of the 2002 original. This 10-digit number is your confirmation number. Related: MCU Phase 4 Can Finish Sony's Original Amazing Spider-Man Plan. Those Though Amazing Spider-Man did well at the box office, the fact remained that it was thoroughly eclipsed by the other Marvel-based movie to come out that year, and that the MCU was showing far more staying power than Sony's spider-flicks. Sure, The Amazing Spider-Man movies inform us of Peter's nerdery. Unfortunately, that's where the list of nice things to say about The Amazing Spider-Man ends. The two Amazing Spider-Man movies did not start off in the exact same place and some fans still feel the films should not have happened. First thing : amazing spiderman 2 was 2 parts like tobey Maguires one and tomorrow Hollands one In retrospect, the writing was very much on the wall: people were falling for Marvel's sunny, quip-laden vision of their own universe far more than with Sony's slick take on the iconic webslinger. The massive leak of Sony emails that flooded the internet in 2015 revealed that, in the minds of some executives, Garfield failed this all-important test when he failed to appear at an event in. By using our Services, you agree to our use of cookies. This Amazing Spider-Man 2 alternate ending goes viral, upset fans say 'Millions don't know this exists' . Amazing spiderman 3 should be released. story/potential story threads, it also had a lot of villains to contend with However, due to some backstage issues between Raimi and the studio, Spider-Man 4 was cancelled. However, there's also so much style and flair in The Amazing Spider-Man 2 compared to Jon Watts' MCU movies too. Coming only 5 years afterSpider-Man 3, Marc Webb's movies were always going to be directly held up against Sam Raimi's work, and might've benefited from more of a tonal and narrative departure. Whether its timeless classics such as Psycho or The Wire, to modern greats such as Parasite or Brooklyn Nine-Nine, Ive spent countless of hours watching (and writing) any movie or television show that I could find. If Amazing spiderman 3 will be released, the fans would get a surprising happy shock. Let us never forget that in his debut in Amazing Fantasy #15, he is bitten by a radioactive spider because he is visiting a lab after school. Main villian is not that good, Green Goblin is useless and Rhino shouldn't have been there. Maguire's Spidey loved to talk chemistry, and Holland's gets together with his best friend Ned to build LEGO models of the Death Star. Theyre justaverage. Despite the financial success of Spiderman 3, the sequel was canceled due to creative differences. The bad news? MCU Spidey'svillains are smart criminals rather than crazed monsters, and the love story doesn't come into full effect until the second movie. Webb's great directorial innovation a series of video game-esque action sequences, viewed from Spider-Man's first-person perspective were goofy-looking with 3D glasses and insufferably dull without them. into the movie, as an extra threat to Spider-Man. The Amazing Spiderman isnt a bad movie. Garfield said that he no-show was because of an illness. Its just an unnecessary one. Regal And I'm so up for it. Outside of Electro and the Green Goblin, the movie also spent a little bit of time with the Rhino a villain who bookended the picture. The premise of a crossover was conceived by Dan Slott, who wrote the core part of the story in The Amazing Spider-Man (vol. As Rolling Stone put it upon the film's release, their young love is the core of the movie. Andrew did a great job. Of the three actors who make up Spidey's screen presence, Garfield is the one whose handsome looks weren't toned down they were, if anything, accentuated with mousse and wardrobe choices. She's the new love interest for series star . He broods with a charisma that is entirely too cool. You can easily cut out his scenes and it wouldnt have changed the plot of The Amazing Spiderman 2. Visit our corporate site (opens in new tab). The sequel fell into the same trappings that Spiderman 3 did. Few make it all the way to red carpet. Before The Amazing Spider-Man premiered, director Marc Webb saidthat he planned to unveil a mystery involving Peter Parker's parents over "a few movies." There are stillplenty of lessons to be learned here. The MCU debuted in 2008 with the explosive arrival of Robert Downey Jr.'s Tony Stark inIron Man. Late Mondaynight, Marvel Studios and Sony announced an unprecedented partnershipdesigned to bring Spider-Man into Marvel's cinematic universe. We now have a textbook example of how not to reboot a superhero franchise, and if Sony and Marvel are wise, they'll take virtually all those lessons to heart as they chart Spider-Man's next course. Moving forward, the original plan was to make a fourth entry in the series, with Sam Raimi back in the directors chair and the majority of the cast set to return for the next chapter. We want to hear what you have to say but need to verify your email. When it comes to superhero blockbusters, two movies is not a franchise; it's a failure. Audiences were enthralled, shawarma chefs rejoiced, and superhero fans everywhere felt the dawn of a new sun on their beleaguered faces. That brings the web-slinger back into The Avengers, where he belongs but it also means the end of the Andrew Garfield-led Amazing Spider-Man series (and no, Garfield won't be reprising the title role). That's basically your whole career. Is The Amazing Spider-Man 2 a weak link in the Spider-Man movie series or is it a film that needs a reappraisal? Who are the villains of Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse? Flash-forward to 2023, and Garner is revisiting her early-aughts rom-com stardom in the long-awaited third season of the cult Starz comedy Party Down. England and Wales company registration number 2008885. If The Amazing Spider-Man series is remembered for anything, it will be Stone's performance. figure. The film has a loyal fan base, but it also has its fair share of disappointed fans. Only five years separate the last of the Maguire trilogy from the first of the Garfield duo. Continuing the theme of too much in one film, The Amazing Electro is poorly portrayed by Jamie Foxx, I love Jamie Foxx, he's a great actor but he just wasn't very good as Electro. While the cast is outstanding and the special effects are top-notch, the latest installment of the Spidey saga suffers from an unfocused narrative and an overabundance of characters. Check. All the 2012 reboot did was remind fans how great the Tobey Maguire series was. Writing and entertainment is in my blood and Im happy that I get a chance to share discuss these topics on a daily basis. garfield is a natural, never tire of mr foxx and coming round to emma stone. But The Amazing Spider-Man was also Sony's only real shot at a multi-billion-dollar superhero, which took the series into its least welcome permutation yet: a desperate attempt to launch a multi-platform cinematic universe before convincingaudiences that The Amazing Spider-Man was interesting on its own merits. The film was well Disney happened, just like with every other Marvel title that has been pulled. How would you rate this article? Living with his great Aunt May. Electro is the one who gets the most character development, but theres nothing particularly memorable about him. All rights reserved. Even . One of the biggest negative reactions to The Amazing Spider-Man 2 was that it simply contained too much set-up for future use, at the expense of focusing on its own story.

Leslie Uggams Parents, Articles W

why amazing spider man 2 failed